Jackson Arrangement 3 Fingering

Found in: Arrangements & Variations, Curriculum

Amy L., California

In teaching Humpty’s Twins (Jackson Blues arrangement 3), I generally teach RH3 for the middle note of all the chords. I had a student today ask why not RH4 for the middle note of the top chord. Thoughts?

Mark M., New York

I teach the same way, and just in the last couple of weeks I had a student ask the exact same question. I was reluctant to allow it, because I do think in the end that 135 is best, but I can see the case for 4 on the top chord depending on students’ hand size, flexibility, etc. I said it was okay with me, choose either way, as long you choose soon and keep it consistent.

Stephen R., California

I honestly prefer 124 fingering throughout! It works great for me or those with big hands, maybe not smaller hands. I suggest one way or the other to students, 135 or 124.

Ian B., California

I think fingering is all about finding the balance between comfort and consistency for students so that fingering is fine as long as I see them doing it consistently and successfully. That said I myself prefer 124 on the first two chords and 135 on the last.

Original discussion started March 14, 2018

Last updated 5 years ago
adapting fingering, alternate fingering for chords, arrange, arrangement, arrangements, big fingers, blues fingering, chord fingering, chords, figuring out fingering, finger 4, finger adaptations, finger positions, fingering, fingering chords, fingers, hand, humpty, Jackson Blues, large hands, learning arrangements, playing-based arrangements, small hands, teacher preparation for arrangements, Teaching Arrangements, teaching arrangements 1 and 2, thick fingers, unfolding arrangements in class

Simpedia